Where do rivals beat it, and what does each gap cost?
Rivals outpaced First National Bank of Morton Grove in lending volume. As of September 30, 1998, the bank reported $279 million in total assets and maintained a 56% loan-to-deposit ratio under the 68% peer-bank average. In 1997, lenders made 104,455 owner-occupied HMDA loans in the bank's assessment area, but First National Bank of Morton Grove originated only 44 of them, or .04%.
First National Bank of Morton Grove ranked 64th among 325 lenders and held a .27% market share. The five banks with the highest market shares within the assessment area were LaSalle Bank FSB at 6%, First Chicago NBD Mortgage Company, Norwest Mortgage and Chase Manhattan Mortgage Company at 3% each, and Citibank FSB at 2%.
Is its category moving in its favor or against it?
Consolidation worked against First National Bank of Morton Grove. The bank operated as a wholly owned subsidiary of MidCity Financial Corporation, a $1.6 billion multi-bank holding company, while banks in the assessment area were similarly situated and independently owned, ranged from $200 million to $600 million in total assets, served similar market areas, and primarily had a commercial lending focus. On November 7, 2001, the bank merged into The Mid-City National Bank of Chicago.
On May 4, 2019, the bank merged into Fifth Third Bank (6672) in Cincinnati, Ohio, and subsequently operated as part of that bank.
Which risks could break the thesis, and what would warn of them?
Concentration risk dominated the bank's profile: commercial lending made up 57% of its loans while its branches were confined to Morton Grove, so the franchise depended on a single local commercial market. As of September 30, 1998, total assets stood at $279 million, with loans representing 50% of total assets. Because branch locations were limited to Morton Grove, most of the bank's small business was generated through officer calls and referrals.
The bank grew 13% over the preceding twelve months, primarily within its commercial and commercial real estate loan portfolios. Consumer originations were significantly lower in 1998 because of the discontinuance of indirect automobile lending.
First National Bank of Morton Grove, primarily a commercial lender, offered a full range of retail and commercial bank products.