PEF outperformed PET in gas barrier and mechanical strength, an edge that Avantium's YXY process and a partner network built to create a PEF supply chain made defensible. The material blocked oxygen, carbon dioxide, and water vapor more effectively, making it an alternative for bottles, films, and food trays, and enabled thinner packaging that used fewer resources.
Synvina's PEF was based on fructose as a renewable raw material. The company aimed to develop PEF as a sustainable bio-based packaging material and to continue development partnerships with Coca-Cola, Danone, ALPLA, and other companies on a joint development platform for PEF bottles.
PET's mature, large-scale production base and lower-cost terephthalic acid beat PEF on cost, leaving PEF with a €1,200 per tonne gap to the PET market price after currency and unit adjustments. Producing PEF carried a total operating cost estimated at roughly $2,700 per ton in the second quarter of 2015.
Terephthalic acid production enjoyed the advantages of mature, large-scale infrastructure, while FDCA production struggled with feedstock availability, conversion efficiency, and capital investment. FDCA raw material costs stayed substantially above terephthalic acid levels. This disparity created an economic barrier to market entry.
The execution risk in Synvina's plan to build a commercial-scale FDCA plant, together with BASF's contractual exit right if investment criteria slipped, could break the business. Synvina planned a mid-three-digit million euro investment in a reference plant with annual capacity of up to 50,000 metric tons at BASF's Verbund site in Antwerp, Belgium, and planned to license the technology for industrial-scale production. Avantium and BASF disagreed on the timing for fulfilling the criteria to invest in the commercial-scale plant for FDCA.
BASF served Avantium notice that it was entitled under the joint venture agreement to exit Synvina if the investment criteria were not fulfilled by 5 December 2018. Synvina aimed to develop a complete supply chain for PEF as a sustainable bio-based packaging material. Synvina aimed to continue development partnerships with Coca-Cola, Danone, ALPLA, and other companies on a joint development platform for PEF bottles.
Synvina was formed to produce and market FDCA, made from renewable resources, and to market PEF based on FDCA, planning to use Avantium's YXY process on fructose, a renewable raw material, to produce it. The venture planned a licensed reference plant of up to 50,000 metric tons a year, and PEF offered a stronger gas barrier than conventional plastics.
The planned plant was located in Belgium, and the technology was to be licensed for industrial-scale production. PEF was suitable for foil pouches, bottles for carbonated and non-carbonated soft drinks, water, dairy products, still and sports drinks, and alcoholic beverages, and personal and home care products.
For packaging, PEF blocked carbon dioxide and oxygen, extending the shelf life of packaged products. PEF was a chemical analogue of PET and PEN.