Mapping the Jensen Huang saga
Read Max
Yesterday
Mapping the Jensen Huang saga
Yesterday
Greetings from Read Max HQ! In this edition, some quick thoughts about Jensen Huang, Nvidia, and the fallout in both Silicon Valley and Washington, D.C. This was, of course, the subject of two (count 'em!) episodes of Hard Fork this week, both available on YouTube and the podcast platform of your choice.
A reminder: Read Max is a subscription concern. If you want access to all our old emails, plus the weekly book-and-movie-and-music recommendations, consider becoming a paid member of the Read Max Patreon here.
The saga of Jensen Huang, recently resigned CEO of the graphics-card company Nvidia, is a very "Read : corporate and national espionage, the ontological status of the "spy" as a figure, institutional politicking and leaking, grey markets and international trade, a dash of sex, and, most of all, flow charts. The reporting around Huang and Megaspeed, the Singaporean data-center company that employed Huang's alleged-spy paramour and seems to have funneled Nvidia chips to mainland China, has so many lovely flow charts, maps, and infographics, like this one from the Times —
— or this beauty from Bloomberg:
What other maps might we draw? One of the things I've been most interested in here is the ways in which the Huang saga both emerges from and scrambles a series of factional fights over China and AI that have consumed Silicon Valley and Washington, D.C. over the past half-decade. Indeed, the story (true and serious though it obviously is!) is so openly driven by warring camps of politicians, executives, and power brokers that the "conspiracy theories" flourishing in the wake of his resignation are not even theories so much as paranoid, ideologically tinged descriptions of what we effectively already know to be true. "If I had to guess we're going to find out that it was a deep state coup in conjunction with China hawks in the admin," Nic Carter tweets — which, well, yes, what tipped you off? The widely reported role of U.S. intelligence in identifying Huang's mistress as a Chinese spy? The China hawks in the administration all but overtly taking credit? You can quibble with "deep state coup" as a descriptor, but that is basically what happened.
At the same time, this makes me think it might be useful to try to sketch out the precise intra-elite disputes driving both the developing news itself and the attention around it. I get the sense that even among enjoyers of good salacious gossip the shock and excitement over Huang's fall has sometimes seemed overblown, and the chatter is perhaps more legible if you understand that it's structured on a deep level by ongoing conflict within the corridors of power. Two ongoing debates in particular, one central to the White House and the other to the AI sector, have been already shaping this story for over a year now:
China hawks vs. (expedient) China doves. This is maybe the most obvious dispute fueling the intensity of the story (if not fueling the story itself in the form of leaks and background): the ongoing efforts of China hawks within the administration, Secretary of State Marco Rubio seemingly chief among them, to take action on the intelligence that Huang was sleeping with a woman who was smuggling Nvidia chips into China (and who was herself apparently a spy of some kind). On the other side of this dispute is Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick — not a "dove," precisely, but in this context certainly not a hawk. Lutnick appears to have been in some capacity protecting Huang and Nvidia from consequences, presumably because he (and his boss, and the rest of the administration, and his sons) were enjoying the surging stock market of which Nvidia was a significant driver.
Open weights vs. closed models. In the tech world, Huang is best understood as the most prominent advocate of open-weight, open-source AI models, a position that puts him at odds with the "frontier labs" of OpenAI and Anthropic, both of whose models are closed and proprietary. There are clear economic reasons for each company to prefer its stance — as a matter of revenue, Nvidia would like a proliferation of many different AI models and companies, which would presumably become Nvidia clients, while Anthropic and OpenAI would prefer to lock in subscribers and charge by the token rather than have anyone host a model on their laptop — but the debate is often cast as an ideological dispute between "safetyists" like Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei and "optimists" like Huang. (And indeed, Huang's ouster has already "added momentum" to congressional efforts to impose stricter chip export controls.)
These two debates have always been interrelated — Chinese open-source models are periodically a real threat to frontier-lab dominance — but they haven't been strictly overlapping, either, and many people have staked out positions orthogonal to Huang's freer-trade-and-open-source or Amodei's AI-safety-and-China-paranoia. The nationalist "tech right" in particular has adopted an aggressive hostility to both China and closed-model safetyism. Now they find themselves confronted with an uncomfortable choice: Defend their pro-open, anti-safety comrade against this political attack? Or condemn him for aiding and abetting their international boogeyman-rival? Unsurprisingly, any number of logically improbable conclusions are being arrived at. Here, e.g., is Anduril founder Palmer Luckey:
It's not clear why Luckey thinks that China "wants Jensen out" — or, for that matter, why China would want him out — but Luckey, an aggressive China hawk, clearly needs to rationalize his own support for Huang within the narrow ideological parameters to which he's committed.
Which ideological parameters is an interesting question. As a matter of class position, the "tech right" is composed of investors and the special class of Silicon Valley executive known as "founders" — domineering, visionary entrepreneurs. On an economic level their interest in open models derives from their investments in smaller AI companies whose survival is threatened by the all-consuming success of OpenAI and Anthropic; in the same way, they fear the Chinese AI sector as a competitor prone to undercutting cost and efficiency. (Those, like Luckey, that are financially entangled with the defense industry have other obvious reasons to maintain an aggressive stance on China.) But perhaps even deeper than these considerations lies a third ideological conflict structuring the Huang saga: controlling, visionary founder-entrepreneurs versus conservative, market-bound corporate managers.
Huang is a prototypical founder; Nvidia's success has emerged not just from his hands-on management style (🥁) but from his ability to make expensive long-term bets (such as on the crypto and AI markets for GPUs) that might have been more constrained in an organization where power was less centralized. For him to be toppled like this — notably, for violating some very basic and obvious corporate norms — is a threat not just to open models or loosened trade with China, but to the position and prerogative of founders. The outsized reaction from the tech right and adjacent figures — naive conspiracy theories like Carter's, incoherent tweets like Luckey's, showy demonstrations of support against all evidence — can be seen as a kind of "Kalecki moment" where the threat to founder power comes not from labor but from government, corporate boards, legal regimes, and institutional investors.
